Umphrey's McGee
Flag this Post?
Smaller venues and smaller crowds might make me go see them again at somepoint. It never fails that drunk kids or idiots get in the way of the music at a UM show. I remember the Park West some time ago, when Mirro was still in the band. Some wook totally freaked out and started puking on himself and reflexively landed his beer all over me as his hands flailed. I was laughing my ass off. I'm definitely not a small person or a hippy in stature so the guy looked at me and who knows if he was seeing a pink monkey at that point, thought I would do something to him and ran to the front door and left the show. It was one of the funniest things I've witnessed at a show but certainly didnt help the overall vibe. It was when mirro was singing and they had some freestyler up there I forget when. It was like 4 songs deep first set that poor wook
doctorg, I definitely have gotten the impression that their midwest popularity has been declining, but I disagree there has been an overall "troubling decline in popularity." They are still growing in certain markets like the Southeast and Northeast especially. In early 2011, they had their best run of straight sell out shows (I think it hit 9 or 10). Also over the last couple of years, they have had sell outs or record attendance at many venues they had not sold out before. And I don't know how you can make the argument that STS9 is doing better when they are playing the same venues.
As far as the quality of the music, it's subjective man. Apparently you don't get that. I think in particular their improv is at a much higher level now than it ever has been. And I still think they are writing a lot of great songs.
As far as the quality of the music, it's subjective man. Apparently you don't get that. I think in particular their improv is at a much higher level now than it ever has been. And I still think they are writing a lot of great songs.
Quote:
Originally Posted by humphrey Quote:
I can see how you're trying to be witty, but if you actually read my post, you'd notice that your reply makes absolutely no sense. |
That's funny because your original post doesn't make sense either.
Quote:
Originally Posted by doctorg If you go to see wappy blueberry vs divisions, well you are just lost. |
Uh, Wappy Sprayberry is a MUCH better song than Divisions, IMO. I think you may be the lost one.
And this:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shpongled As far as the quality of the music, it's subjective man. Apparently you don't get that. I think in particular their improv is at a much higher level now than it ever has been. And I still think they are writing a lot of great songs. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Noster_Putbags In unbridled epicness? |
dumb question
I know I will never like phish as much as others because I missed their "epic " years. I enjoyed the one phish show I've been to but nothing about them makes me want to really get into their catalog or shows. Their lyrics are pretty lame, the music behind them is great but I really didn't feel they went into any real jams that were anything ordinary. Phish is a good time where as Umphrey's just an absolute rage fest. Here's how the bands stack up in the "jam" category
UM and moe. are the purest jammers on my opinion
Cheese gets out there pretty good
Phish really doesn't go far but can get crazy, songs are worst out of jam scene
Panic is probably the band that has the least actual improv but theory Type 1 style jamming with Some strait up rock and roll songs/music I would rank them ahead of the Phish as well
Furthur is a great rendition of dead tunes when they are on, but I have not personally seen them play a good show. Some of the best music ever written.
Umphrey's
moe.
Panic
Furthur/Dead
Cheese
Phish .....that's the order in which I would spend my money
UM and moe. are the purest jammers on my opinion
Cheese gets out there pretty good
Phish really doesn't go far but can get crazy, songs are worst out of jam scene
Panic is probably the band that has the least actual improv but theory Type 1 style jamming with Some strait up rock and roll songs/music I would rank them ahead of the Phish as well
Furthur is a great rendition of dead tunes when they are on, but I have not personally seen them play a good show. Some of the best music ever written.
Umphrey's
moe.
Panic
Furthur/Dead
Cheese
Phish .....that's the order in which I would spend my money
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shpongled doctorg, I definitely have gotten the impression that their midwest popularity has been declining, but I disagree there has been an overall "troubling decline in popularity." They are still growing in certain markets like the Southeast and Northeast especially. In early 2011, they had their best run of straight sell out shows (I think it hit 9 or 10).
|
This. There has been a steady rise in sell outs all over the country (more in the East than out west, but there too) for UM in the last year and half. Last winter they sold out the majority of the first few legs of the tour, and so far this year have sold out every show except for one. Most of them at venues that they haven't sold out (at least in a while)
Quote:
Originally Posted by opsopcopolis Quote:
This. There has been a steady rise in sell outs all over the country (more in the East than out west, but there too) for UM in the last year and half. Last winter they sold out the majority of the first few legs of the tour, and so far this year have sold out every show except for one. Most of them at venues that they haven't sold out (at least in a while) |
True but we are talking clubs and theaters.
Personally I love UM's size and hope they remain in clubs & theaters.
[quote=FroDaddyJR24]I know I will never like phish as much as others because I missed their "epic " years. I enjoyed the one phish show I've been to but nothing about them makes me want to really get into their catalog or shows. Their lyrics are pretty lame, the music behind them is great but I really didn't feel they went into any real jams that were anything ordinary. Phish is a good time where as Umphrey's just an absolute rage fest. Here's how the bands stack up in the "jam" category
UM and moe. are the purest jammers on my opinion
Cheese gets out there pretty good
Phish really doesn't go far but can get crazy, songs are worst out of jam scene
Panic is probably the band that has the least actual improv but theory Type 1 style jamming with Some strait up rock and roll songs/music I would rank them ahead of the Phish as well
Furthur is a great rendition of dead tunes when they are on, but I have not personally seen them play a good show. Some of the best music ever written.
Umphrey's
moe.
Panic
Furthur/Dead
Cheese
Phish .....that's the order in which I would spend my money
Thats what I'm saying....huge fans of moe. and um, they just bring pure jamming rock and roll....gotta love some panic as well they just play good southern rock with a lil jamming.......phish is good too but some of their songs lyrics are just too abstract for ME, although the music is still great
UM and moe. are the purest jammers on my opinion
Cheese gets out there pretty good
Phish really doesn't go far but can get crazy, songs are worst out of jam scene
Panic is probably the band that has the least actual improv but theory Type 1 style jamming with Some strait up rock and roll songs/music I would rank them ahead of the Phish as well
Furthur is a great rendition of dead tunes when they are on, but I have not personally seen them play a good show. Some of the best music ever written.
Umphrey's
moe.
Panic
Furthur/Dead
Cheese
Phish .....that's the order in which I would spend my money
Thats what I'm saying....huge fans of moe. and um, they just bring pure jamming rock and roll....gotta love some panic as well they just play good southern rock with a lil jamming.......phish is good too but some of their songs lyrics are just too abstract for ME, although the music is still great
moe. fucking sucks people.
Give me a break.
Give me a break.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Phan_Halen Quote:
True but we are talking clubs and theaters. Personally I love UM's size and hope they remain in clubs & theaters. |
Fuck that, I want to see a Phish sized light rig with Jefferson at the helm! And more room to fuckin dance. I like the sound of bigger venues better too.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GooPhish Quote:
Fuck that, I want to see a Phish sized light rig with Jefferson at the helm! And more room to fuckin dance. I like the sound of bigger venues better too. |
As long as it never was hard to get a ticket. Like it is now.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GooPhish Quote:
Fuck that, I want to see a Phish sized light rig with Jefferson at the helm! And more room to fuckin dance. I like the sound of bigger venues better too. |
I'd rather continue paying $25-35 for most tickets, stand or sit wherever I want, and enjoy the intimacy and character that those smaller venues have. There really isn't anything I can think of that I prefer about arena venues to the average theatre.
Quote:
Originally Posted by saladbarjam already have in my opinion which I am entitled to as an American citizen.... |
I may not agree with your opinion but I will fight to the death your right to have it.
I have no doubt in my mind that UM could rock an arena should they ever get that big.
But i dont know why anyone would want that.
But i dont know why anyone would want that.
bump
I think they would have had a legitimate shot while Phish was gone if they would have been on a real record label.
No....they are very awesome, and they bring it....but their music doesn't have enough "hooks."
Phish nor the Dead were ever pop, but their music had many catchy elements and got people singing along.
And anyway, current Phish will never surpass what Phish used to be...
Phish nor the Dead were ever pop, but their music had many catchy elements and got people singing along.
And anyway, current Phish will never surpass what Phish used to be...
Im not sure is UM will surpass Phish, but as a pretty long time Phish fan (since 95') I have not been so "taken back" by a bands sound since Phish 1.0. I don't know what took me so long to catch on but Im hooked now. I love the covers they play. Will they ever surpass Phish? NO...
please stay in small venues - however they will move up slowly to bigger places (just look at the fox in oaktown)<-gonna be an awesome night - which sucks in a way once they get to bigger non intimate arenas, get your kicks in now
They play the biggest venue they've ever played on the west coast and then the next night they are playing a 350 capacity bar, fucking awesome, I will be there
moe. doesn't suck
They play the biggest venue they've ever played on the west coast and then the next night they are playing a 350 capacity bar, fucking awesome, I will be there
moe. doesn't suck
You must be logged in order to post.
Contact
|
Terms of Service
|
Privacy Policy
|
Advertise
© 1999-2010 Phantasy Tour, LLC. All rights reserved.
© 1999-2010 Phantasy Tour, LLC. All rights reserved.
Lovingly rendered by Basis
just for you in 0.038216726 seconds.
Welcome, please login.